Caprica was OK (got a lot better in it's end run), but the lack of RDM was keenly felt (to me, anyway). For better or worse, he is the
soul of the NuBSG franchise.
I fear that any future BSG endeavor without his name (ala most of Caprica and Blood & Chrome) will just miss the mark.
David Eick is little more than a very talented producer, not writer or anything else (we've seen
proof of this in his episodes and decisions for the franchise; as well as his sh***y Bionic Woman revival).
Michael Taylor gives me hope though (he 'gets it').
But again, as much as I'd love to see the pilot movie, this is one trip to the well too many...