Got issue 2 today; more mixed emotions...
******** SPOILERS!!!! *********
Adama lingers on the edge of death after the Galactica is shot down over the White House. Dr Mortensen (still sporting Robert Reed's '70s afro) realizes that the intercepted radio messages from the Galacticans is something akin to ancient Aramaic, and he rushes to the scene of the crash. As Troy and Dillon attempt to rescue Adama from the wreckage of the ol' G, Dillon is shot by US troops (who are falling ill to radiation from the nuclear missile used to shoot down G). Meanwhile, aboard the Rising Star, Dr Zee declares "cerebral law" (like martial law, only for brainiacs I presume...) and wrestles control from Col Boomer and the council of the 12. The end of issue two has Baltar and Lucifer (aboard a basestar; complete with piano and reading room) realizing that Adama has found Earth and they are preparing to join the party...
Like: Like last time, love the action, and the sinister spin on Dr Zee; loved the return of Baltar (now sporting a metal plate on one side of his face) as well as Lucifer; that was a welcome twist (even if Baltar's youthful visage doesn't really convey the passage of time; Adama still has his G1980 goatee and Troy is still 30-something, so why hasn't Baltar aged??). The Galacticans speaking a variation of Aramaic was also a nice twist; very much in keeping with Galactica ideology. Nice renderings of TOS vipers, sets (the bridge), and Cylon baseships, too.
Dislike: Col Boomer and the council can't wrestle control of the fleet from a bratty kid (unarmed, at that)??? Too many Ronald Moore-isms as well. The characters look like classic TOS BSG characters but have potty mouths right out of NuBSG (again; it doesn't fit this universe or TOS mythology... I don't mind explorations, but stay true to your source characters). And did Dr Zee REALLY need to have
Gaius as
his first name as well???? Show just a
hint of imagination on that one, OK??? That just tells me that the writers of this series just want to rub RDM's BSG scent all over TOS BSG; and again, it
doesn't work. Two very
different mindsets, here.
Perhaps the thing to do for these writers would've been to actually
watch TOS and get a feel for how the characters speak and the rhythms of their dialogue.
As it is? It's basically a TOS rendering of NuBSG, with elements from G1980. Kind of a hot mess; but an
intriguing hot mess at times...